Monday, March 25, 2019

FIRE IN NEW YORK CITY

3/25/1911 - Designed by John Woolley in an architectural style known as neo-Renaissance, the ten-story iron and steel Asch Building goes up in New York City at 23-29 Washington Place (at the site where writer Henry James, Jr. was born, the location is on the corner of Greene Street and Washington Place), in the Greenwich Village neighborhood of Manhattan between 1900 and 1901.  Named for it's owner, businessman Joseph J. Asch, the loft structure instantly begins attracting tenants in the garment business for its newness and the security of it's terra-cotta "fireproof" rooms ... but the structure is not fireproof at all, because it stands only 135 feet high, unlike structures of over 150 feet in height, it is allowed to have wooden floors, wood window frames and trim, and a sprinkler system inside is not required.
Image result for asch building construction
The Asch Building

Occupying the top three levels of the structure is the Triangle Shirtwaist Company of Russian-born Jewish immigrants Max Blanck and Isaac Harris, the era's "Shirtwaist Kings" (the men have a history with fires ... their Triangle operation has been scorched twice in 1902, and their Diamond Waist Factory burned down twice, in 1907 and 1910, conflagrations that the men received insurance money for both times) manufacturers of the popular shirtwaist, a high-necked blouse usually made of light, crisp translucent cotton or sheer linen that had come into fashion at the end of the previous century, due in large part to it being featured on the models of "Gibson Girl" illustrator, Charles Dana Gibson.  The company's profits exceeding a million dollars a year by 1908 (the blouses sell for roughly $3), Harris supervises garment production, overseeing the machinery and workflow of the employees, while Blanck is in charge of sales (though Triangle is their largest enterprise, the men also own shirtwaist facilities elsewhere in New York City, Newark, New Jersey, and Philadelphia, Pennsylvania).  In 1911, the company employees roughly 600 individuals, most of them easily replaceable teenage girls just arrived in America from Russia and Italy that don't speak English and can't protest working conditions and wages ... employees work as late as to 9:00 at night during the peak season with no overtime pay or a supper break, have shifts that call for nine hour days during the week, and seven hours days on Saturday and Sunday (for which they are paid between $7 and $12 a week), although against the law, doors are kept locked to prevent keep employees from absconding with company property, workers are searched day before leaving for home to make sure they haven't stolen anything, doors at the factory swing in instead of out, there are four elevators with access to the factory floor, but only one is operational, the women aren't allowed to join the Ladies Garment Workers Union (thugs are hired to deal with strikers and political payments are made for authorities to look the other way), there are no fire alarms in the building, and though more were promised as part of the original build, the building has only one fire escape.  Tragedy awaiting only a spark, the spark comes as the factory's work day is ending, at 4:40 on a Saturday afternoon.
Charles Dana Gibson 02.jpg
Gibson
Image result for gibson girls shirtwaist fashion
Shirtwaist Fashion 
Max Blanck and Isaac Harris, owners of the Tri...
Max Blanck & Isaac Harris 
Image result for triangle shirtwaist fire victims
Before

Fire breaks out in a scrap bin on the 8th floor filled with two months of the factory's cuttings, hundreds of pounds of material in a wooden bin, under a wooden table, surrounded by hanging fabrics.  The culprit, though smoking is banned, with no breaks, employees sneak smokes while on the floor, and someone deposited a still warm cigarette butt in the bin.  Water buckets on the floor to put out just such a fire prove inadequate, and when a shipping clerk tries to put out the fire with a hose, he is horrified to discover that not only has the hose rotted, its valve has rusted shut ... the flames are soon out of control and chaos soon reigns in the building.  At 4:45 the first fire alarm is given when a passerby on the street below sees smoke coming from the 8th floor.  Inside, a bookkeeper on the 8th floor, Dinah Lifschitz, calls on the telephone to warn the 10th floor of what is taking place below, information which Blanck and Harris use to immediately flee to the roof and then across to another building to safety with members of their families, two of Blanck's daughters and their governess, who are visiting the operation (thanks to Professor Frank Sommer and his law student class next door, placing ladders left by painters, across to the 10th floor of the Asch Building, in all, 69 of the 70 individuals on the 10th floor when the fire breaks out will be saved).  The 8th floor, aware of the flames, escapes downward, the 10th floor goes up and over the roof, but the 9th floor suddenly finds itself in mortal danger ... the stairway down to Washington Place is locked and the supervisor with its key has already fled, withing three minutes, the Greene Street stairway becomes unusable in both directions, the single exterior fire escape collapses from the heat and overcrowding, sending 20 employees to their deaths on the street a 100 feet below, and with the two elevators giving access on to and off of the floor, both soon made non-operational by the raging flames, able to take only 12 people to safety at a time, elevator operator heroes Joseph Zito and Gaspar Mortillalo, risking their own lives, are able to rescue 150 souls (after the elevators break down, prying the doors of the elevator open, more employees plunge to their deaths in the shaft trying to climb down the elevator cables, 36 in all, and four hours later, after the holocaust has finally been put out, its last survivor will be found in the rising waters inside the shaft).  And even when New York firefighters arrive on the scene their rescue efforts seem cursed; the fire department's ladders only reach six stories high, and its jump nets prove inadequate, jumpers tear straight through the netting to the cement sidewalks, or bounce out with the same result ... death for the jumper.
Image result for asch building
Layout Of The Tragedy
The flimsy fire escape ladder
The Fire Escape Wreckage

South Side Of The Building - Where 50 Jumped

Rushing To The Fire
Image of Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire on March 25 - 1911.jpg
The Asch Building On Fire

A hell of fire and smoke, employees of the Triangle Shirtwaist Company die from fire, smoke inhalation, and the smashings they take when trying to escape the other two killers, they jump away from the flaming building to the streets below (over sixty by some estimates, often holding the hands of another jumper, some experiencing a last kiss before leaping, and many plummeting, already on fire) ... scenes of horror that fire fighters, police, and witnesses (over ten thousand will rush to the scene, including dozens of pick pockets taking advantage of the situation) will remember for the rest of their lives (a reporter will write, "I learned a new sound that day, a sound more horrible than description can picture - the thud of a speeding living body on to a stone sidewalk.").  Minutes of forever, the fire is out 18 minutes after its start, taking 146 lives with it ... 123 women and 23 men, the oldest victim is 43-year-old Providenza Pannino, the youngest victims are 14-year-olds Kate Leone and Rosario Maltese.  Corpses removed, the dead are brought to Charities Pier on 26th Street (also called "Misery Lane") where they are placed in simple wooden coffins for identification by their families prior to internment in a host of local cemeteries (six, unidentified at first, will be buried in Brooklyn's Cemetery of the Evergreens ... over 100 years later, it will take historian, Michael Hirsch, four long years of research to eventually identify them by name).
Image result for triangle shirtwaist fire
Carnage
Image result for triangle shirtwaist fire victims
Victims
Image result for triangle shirtwaist fire victims
On The Street Below
Image result for triangle shirtwaist fire victims
Inside - After
Image result for triangle shirtwaist fire victims
At The Pier

Deaths not in vain, in the aftermath of the tragedy, over 80,000 people will march on 4/5 through the streets of New York City in protest of the working conditions the women faced, and in October, the state will pass the Sullivan-Hoey Fire Prevention Law (between 1911 and 1914, thirty-six new labor laws will be enacted to protect workers), also in October, the American Society of Safety Professionals is created, and a nine-member Factory Investigating Committee is created to investigate safety and working conditions in New York factories.  And of course, given the circumstances, Blanck and Harris go on trial for the deaths of their 146 employees.  Indicted two weeks after the fire on charges of first and second degree manslaughter, the pair are prosecuted by Assistant District Attorney Charles S. Bostwick, and defended by famous New York attorney, Max David Steuer.  Trial beginning on December 4, 1911, in the courtroom of Judge Thomas Crain, Bostwick presents 103 witnesses, while Steuer puts up 52.  It all takes two weeks ... on 12/27 the judge charges the jury using the test of Article 6, Section 80 of New York's Labor Law ... and only two hours later, both men are incredibly found not guilty, jurors deeming there was no hard evidence that the pair "knew" the stairwell to safety from floor #9 was locked (Bostwick will go after the men again in 1912, but Judge Samuel Seabury will throw out the case, deeming it constitutes double-jeopardy over a matter already tried) ... escorted by five police officers, the pair flee the upset citizens of New York (screaming "Justice. Where is Justice?") through the judge's chamber and private entrance, barely beating a mob to the nearby subway station.  In civil suits over the matter, in 1913 plaintiffs in twenty-three individual cases are awarded an average of $75 for each life lost (while Blanck and Harris receive a payout of $60,000 from their insurance company).
bostwick1
Bostwick
Image result for max david steuer
Steuer
Triangle Harris 3 500.jpg
Listening To Testimony        .

Over a century ago, the fire has had its tale told in films and on television, with music, theatre, and dance, and in literature.  The Asch Building still exists in New York City, but it is now called the Brown Building and is part of the campus of New York University (it is deemed a National Historical Landmark in 1991 and is designated a New York City landmark in 2003).  The last living survivor of the fire, Rose Freedman, dies in her Beverly Hills home in February of 2001 at the age of 107.
Image result for rose freedman triangle fire
Rose
Image result for rose freedman triangle fire
Rose
Image result for triangle fire headlines
Headlines




Thursday, March 21, 2019

ALCATRAZ CLOSES

3/21/1963 - Alcatraz.  Decades after its closure by Attorney General Robert F. Kennedy as a Federal penitentiary in San Francisco Bay, the name still conjures visions of cold and confinement ... concrete walls, steel bars, chilling fog, drowning waters, circling sharks, and crime hardened men, both guards and convicts.  On this March Thursday morning, the United States Penitentiary, Alcatraz Island (also known simply as The Rock), ceases operations as a keeper of men after only 29-years of usage.
Image result for alcatraz prison
The Rock

1,675 feet (length) by 590 feet (width), its highest point 135 feet above the Pacific Ocean, the 22 acres of rock bearing the Spanish word for pelican lays 1.25 miles off the California coast, and prior to its use as a Federal prison, serves the United States government (purchased by John C. Fremont for $5,000 during the Bear Flag Rebellion) as a lighthouse, coastal fortification protecting San Francisco, a storage area for firearms (to keep them out of the hands of Confederate sympathizers during the Civil War), and as a military prison for the United States Army.  Acquired by the United States Department of Justice on October 12, 1933, the facilities on the island are modified and expanded into a penitentiary designed to hold notorious convicts and inmates with records of causing troubles at other facilities.  Guarded by 60 special FBI, U.S. Marshals, and railroad security officers, at 9:40 in the Saturday morning of August 11, 1934, the prison and its staff of 155, accepts its first batch of 137 handcuffed prisoners from Leavenworth Penitentiary in Kansas and the McNeil Island Penitentiary in Washington. 

Alcatraz - 1895

Built for security, not rehabilitation, with a capacity for 315 prisoners, the facility consists of an enclosed three-story cellhouse divided into four blocks of cells, labeled A, B, C, and D (where the prisoners were sent for the additional punishment of solitary confinement in "dark" cells), two barred gun galleries, the warden's office, a visitation room, a library, a barber shop, a dining room and kitchen (three meals a day are provided to both convicts and guards), and above the dining hall, a small hospital.  The cell each convict is essentially assigned to do not adjoin to any outside walls and consist of a barred room that is 9 feet long, five feet wide, and seven feet tall, and contains bed, desk, washbasin (cold water only until the 1960s), and toilet against the back wall (flushed with salt water from the ocean), and basically have no furnishing other than a blanket ... a vent covered by a metal grill measuring 6 inches by 9 inches lets in air from the utility corridor behind the cells  Outside the cellhouse there is a walled-in area for brief bouts of recreation, an Industries building (jobs are considered a privilege), a dock area, facilities for guards and their families, and armed gun towers with searchlights (along with locks, bars, and guards, convicts moving from various areas must pass through metal detectors).  A prison meant to house the "worst of the worst" (among the convicts that spend time on The Rock are Al "Scarface" Capone, the "Dean of Bankrobbers," Harvey Bailey, the "Birdman of Alcatraz, murderer, Robert Franklin Stroud, kidnapper George "Machine Gun" Kelly, Los Angeles gangster Mickey Cohen, Boston mob boss Whitey Bulger, Harlem kingpin "Bumpy" Johnson, U.S. Capitol building shooter Rafael Cancel Miranda, Barker Gang robber and killer Arthur "Dock" Barker, and Public Enemy #1, bank robber and kidnapper, Alvin "Creepy" Karpis, who will spend more time incarcerated on Alcatraz Island than any other prisoner), the facility quickly picks up a reputation for its hostile conditions (on November 13, 1937, murderer Ed Wutke will become the first prisoner on the island to commit suicide ... he will not be the last) and being escape-proof.
Image result for machine gun kelly on alcatraz
Convict Recreation - Machine Gun Kelly Without Hat
Image result for alcatraz cellhouse Layout
Image result for alcatraz cellhouse Cellhouse
Image result for alcatraz cellhouse
Cellhouse And Recreation Area
Image result for criminal edward wutke Wutke

During its existence as a Federal prison, four men will administer the facility as wardens for the Department of Justice ... James A. Johnston from 1934 to 1948, Edwin B. Swope from 1948 to 1955, Paul J. Madigan from 1955 to 1961, and Olin G. Blackwell from 1961 to 1963.  1,576 prisoners will experience the Alcatraz hard of the four wardens ... and in 14 different attempts, 36 convicts will attempt to leave the island before their sentences are fully served.
James A. Johnston.jpg Edwin B. Swope.jpg Paul J. Madigan.jpg Olin G. Blackwell.jpg
L to R - Johnson, Swope, Madigan, And Blackwell

Willing to brave bars, guards, razor sharp rocks, sharks, and seasonal waters in San Francisco Bay that average 53 degrees and have a current that can exceed six knots, the escape attempts begin in 1936 and end in 1962:
*4/27/1936 - While burning trash in an outside incinerator, Joseph Bowers (40, serving a 25-year sentence for mail robbery) suddenly breaks into a run, climbs a chain link fence and ignores commands that he surrender ... shot, he falls fifty feet and dies.
Joseph Bowers Bowers
*12/16/1937 - Theodore Cole (25, serving a life sentence for an Oklahoma robbery and murder) and Ralph Roe (32, serving a lie sentence for partnering with manic Wilbur Underhill ... he is captured in the same gun battle that claims the life of the "Tri-State Terror") file their way out of the Industries Building on a foggy day, make their way down to the water, and slip away from the island, believed drowned by both the convicts and the authorities.
Theodore Cole Cole
Ralph Roe Roe
*5/23/1938 - Rufus Franklin (24, at Alcatraz for on a 30-year beef for bank robbery, car theft, and assault), Thomas Limerick (36, serving a life sentence for bank robbery), and James Lucas (26, serving a 30-year sentence for Texas bank robbery and trafficking in stolen vehicles ... on Alcatraz he is also the convict who attacks Al Capone with a pair of scissors for cutting to the front of the line to get his hair cut in the prison's barber shop), kill guard Royal Cline (36) with a claw hammer, make their way to the roof of the Industries Building.  On the roof, Franklin and Limerick will be gunned down (Limerick is killed by a round to the head) by the tower guard on duty (Franklin survives his shoulder wound and gets life for murder, he dies behind bars in 1975 at the age of 59), and Lucas surrenders (receiving a life sentence also, he is eventually freed and dies in Sacramento in 1998 at the age of 86).
Rufus Franklin Franklin
Thomas R. Limerick Limerick
Lucas NARA Photo.jpg Lucas
*1/13/1939 - Dock Barker (40, serving a life sentence for the kidnapping of St. Paul banker Edward G. Brenner), William Martin (25, serving 25 years for post office robbery), Rufus McCain (36, serving 99 years for kidnapping during a failed Oklahoma bank robbery, Henri Young (28, sentenced to 20 years for a Washington bank job), and Dale Stamphill (27, in for life for the kidnapping of Dr. Fred L. Meyers after an Oklahoma bank robbery) saw their way out of their cells, pry open the bars to an outside window, and make their way to the water ... until cornered by guards, four of the men surrender, but Barker and Stamphill continued to try to escape on the driftwood raft they have crafted, actions that get Stamphill shot in both his legs, and Barker dead from wounds to his neck and head.  Later, supposedly for botching the escape, Young will kill McCain, stabbing his former partner in the stomach.
Arthur Barker Barker
Rufus McCain McCain
William Martin Martin
Dale Stamphill Stamphill
Henri Young Young
*5/21/1941 - Joseph Paul "Dutch" Cretzer (28, in for life for bank robbery, murder, and an escape attempt in Tacoma, Washington), Lloyd Barkdoll (47, life for an Oregon bank robbery), Arnold Kyle (27, Cretzer's brother-in-law and bank robbing partner serving a life sentence), and Sam Shockley, (31, serving a life sentence for bank robbery and kidnapping in Oklahoma) take three guards prisoner in the Industries Building (Clyne Stoops, Lionel Johnstone, and Captain Paul Madigan), along with Superintendent of Industries, C.J. Manning, but realizing they can't grind through the bars of the mat shop, surrender to Madigan after two hours.
Lloyd H. Barkdoll Barkdoll
Joseph Paul Cretzer Cretzer
Arnold Thomas Kyle Kyle
Sam R. Shockley Shockley
*9/15/1941 - On garbage detail, John Richard Bayless (27, serving 25 years for bank robbery in Missouri) manages to slip into the fog and reach the south side of the island ... realizing after moments he will drown if he continues to swim towards San Francisco, he quickly makes his way back to shore and surrenders.
John R. Bayless Bayless
*4/14/1943 - James Boarman (24, in for 20 years for bank robbery), Harold Brest (29, serving a life sentence plus 50 years for bank robbery and kidnapping), Floyd Hamilton (36, the former friend of killer Clyde Barrow, and the brother of executed murderer Raymond Hamilton, at Alcatraz on a 30-year term for bank robbery), and Fred Hunter (43, the former running mate of Alvin Karpis, serving a sentence of 25 years for robbery and harboring Karpis) put together an escape that includes getting out of the mat shop, assembling empty cans into a flotation device, tying up two guards (including Captain of the Guards, Henry Weinhold, covering themselves in grease, and jumping off a 30 foot cliff into the water ... alarm sounded however before they can get away, tower guards fire on the men, killing Boarman, Brest surrenders to guards in the prison's launch, an injured Hunter surrenders after he takes refuge in a nearby cave, and worn out after three days of exposure hiding in the same refuse filled cave, Hamilton surprises guards by climbing out of his hiding place, making his way back to the window he had jumped out of, and hiding under a pile of material in the storeroom of the Industries Building, where Weinhold finds him while searching for items used in the failed escape.
James A. Boarman Boarman
Harold Martin Brest Brest
Floyd G. Hamilton Hamilton
Fred Hunter Hunter
*8/7/1943 - Ted H. Walters (30, serving a 30[year term for bank robbery, assault, and auto theft in Arkansas) sneaks out of a door in the prison laundry and makes his way to the western side of the island ... where missed and alarms sounded, he is captured by the prison's beach patrol.
Ted Huron Walters Walters
*7/31/1943 - John Giles (50, serving 25 years for the attempted robbery of a Denver & Rio Grande Western mail train) almost gets away ... gathering components under the prison's pier of an Army Staff Sergeant's uniform from the prison laundry, Giles jumps aboard the Army launch of General Frank M. Coxe as it completes its business at Alcatraz and heads for nearby Fort McDowell, but an unexpected convict count shows him missing, and guessing as to his whereabouts, he is met as he departs the boat by Assistant Warden E.J. Miller, who taken a speed boat to the army post (with an assist from Lt. Gordon Kilgore who notices tat the convicts uniform is not correct).
John K. Giles Giles       
*5/2 - 5/4/1946 - Clarence Carnes (19, serving life for kidnapping, robbery, and murder), Bernard Paul Coy (46, serving 25 years for bank robbery in Kentucky), Dutch Cretzer (35, serving life for aforementioned crimes plus his failed Alcatraz escape attempt of 1941), Marvin Hubbard (34, serving life for robbery, prison escape, and kidnapping), Sam Shockley (36, as with Cretzer and the 1941 escape attempt), Miran Edgar "Buddy" Thompson (29, serving life for kidnapping and murder in Texas) participate in a flawed escape that has the men procure weapons from the prison's west gun gallery (Coy finds a way to climb three stories, pry the bars apart, and gain the guard Bert Burch's' weapons after the men have a savage fist fight) but get trapped inside the cellhouse when they accidentally jam the lock leading outside ... in the mayhem that ensues, guards William Miller and Harold Stites are killed by Cretzer, eleven corrections officers and one convict not involved in the breakout are wounded, Marine support is called in, Cretzer kills Coy in one of the prison's utility corridors, Hubbard and Cretzer are gunned down in the same utility corridor by guards armed with machine guns and shotguns, Thompson and Shockley are found guilty of murder and executed in the San Quentin gas chamber, and Carnes receives another life sentence to serve (he eventually is released in 1973, breaches the terms of his parole, and is sent back to prison where he dies of AIDS in 1988 at the age of 61).
Battle of Alactraz.jpg
Shooting Up The Cellhouse
 Hubbard, Coy & Cretzer
 Carnes, Shockley, and Thompson 
*7/23/1956 - Floyd Wilson (41, serving life for murder during a bungled robbery attempt) slips away from a work detail and hides in a depression at the foot of some cliffs on the south end of the island ... unable to build a raft and unwilling to get in the water, he surrenders to authorities when he is found eleven hours later.
Floyd P. Wilson Wilson
*9/29/1958 - Aaron Walter Burgett (28, serving 28 years for a Missouri post office robbery) and Clyde Johnson (40, serving 40 years for bank robbery in Tennessee) while outside the walls on garbage detail on a foggy afternoon, use a shiv to take guard Harold Miller hostage while they wait on an escape boat that never shows ... alarm sounded when the three men are missed, Miller is released from the tree he has been tied to, Johnson is recaptured standing hip deep in the Bay's cold waters, and after thirteen days, the body of Burgett is discovered drowned, his wooden flippers and plastic bag having failed to keep him afloat.
Aaron Walter Burgett Burgett
Clyde Johnson Johnson
*6/11/1962 - Clarence Anglin (31, serving 17 years for bank robbery in Alabama), John William Anglin (32, doing 10 years for the same crime as his brother), and Frank Lee Morris (35, serving 14 years for bank burglary in Slidell, Louisiana), after months of planning and preparation that includes the creation of dummy heads, make their way out of the air vents in the back of their cells, climb to the top of a utility corridor, climb though an air vent to the cellhouse roof, lower themselves to the ground, make their way over a wall, and using flotation devices of their own creation, vanish into the San Francisco night without any of the guards knowing it, never to be seen again ... a caper that will be made into a major Hollywood movie starring Clint Eastwood, and an escape that many believe the convicts pull of, despite authorities claiming all they men have drowned.
Clarence Anglin Clarence
John William Anglin John William
Frank Lee Morris Morris
 Morris's Dummy Head
*12/16/1962 - Darl Lee Parker (31, serving 50 years for bank robbery, kidnapping, and an attempted escape) and John Paul Scott (35, serving 30 years for bank robbery and possession of an unregistered gun), while on culinary duty, manage to cut their way through the bars of a storage room in the kitchen, make their way to the western end of the island, using "water wings" made of surgical gloves and prison shirt-sleeves, swim away from the island ... within 25 minutes of an alarm going out that the men have gone missing, Parker is found clinging to a pile of rocks 100 yards off the island called "Little Alcatraz," while the next morning, authorities receive notice of a body being spotted under the Golden Gate Bridge, on the rocks near Fort Point, three miles west of the prison.  It is Scott, but he is not dead, only unconscious and suffering from shock ... revived, he is returned to Alcatraz (transferred to Leavenworth when Alcatraz closes, and then the Federal pen at Marion, Illinois, he makes another escape attempt there, is caught, sent to the Oak Park Heights prison in Minnesota, and eventually dies behind bars at the Federal Correction Facility at Tallahassee, Florida in 1987 at the age of 60).
Darl Lee Parker Parker
John Paul Scott Scott

In the aftermath of the Morris and Anglin's escape (there is an abundance of finger pointing as to who and what is responsible for the prisoners getting out of their cells and vanishing), with structural damage caused by the salt water and air that will cost millions to fix (in 1961 a group of engineers determines that repairing the prison is a lost cause), with the facility more than three times costlier to run than other prisons in the Federal system, Attorney General Robert F. Kennedy decides to close Alcatraz and open a new penitentiary in Marion, Illinois.  Convicts transferred, the prison closes on March 21, 1963 ... but lives on in movies, books, television shows, the memories of guards and convicts that served there, and as a tourist destination making millions off its 1.5 million annual visitors for the city of San Francisco and the Federal government. 
Image result for alcatraz tours
Where Public Enemies Were Once Kept       
Image result for alcatraz tours Tour Completed